Can you trade in games at Gamestop for other ones?

Ok so this game called Alice:Madness Returns came out recently. It won't work on my computer(for some reason) so I saw it was for the XBox too. It costs...pricey...and my brother doesn't want to get me ANY GAMES EVEN THOUGH HE STUFFS HIMSELF WITH THEM. So I wanna know if I can trade in my Sims 3 for Alice:Madness Returns or rent it.....Please help me T_T I NEED HELP! THIS IS THE FIRST GAME I'VE EVER WANTED! AHHHHHHH! (or American McGee's Alice) WAAAA